Quick take: Capital One 360 is the rare hybrid — full-service online CD platform plus a national branch + Capital One Café footprint if you want a human. APYs run 3.85–4.50% across 6mo–5yr, $0 minimum, FDIC. Solid product. Watch-outs: no bump-up, no no-penalty option, and (critically) no partial withdrawals — break a 5-year CD early and you crack the whole thing. For 5+ year money, a MYGA at ~5.50% beats a 5-year 360 CD at 3.85% by about $20K on $250K.
Hans is independently licensed and is NOT affiliated with Capital One or any bank. CD information below is sourced from Capital One's public rate pages and FDIC filings as of June 2026 and rotates frequently — confirm current rates at capitalone.com before deciding.
| Term | APY | $100K Earnings at Maturity | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| 6 months | ~4.25% | ~$2,100 | — |
| 9 months | ~4.10% | ~$3,055 | — |
| 1 year | ~4.50% | ~$4,500 | Sweet spot of the curve |
| 18 months | ~4.20% | ~$6,310 | — |
| 2 years | ~3.95% | ~$8,055 | — |
| 3 years | ~3.85% | ~$11,995 | — |
| 4 years | ~3.85% | ~$16,310 | — |
| 5 years | ~3.85% | ~$20,800 | Best MYGA comp = ~5.50% |
Minimum deposit: $0. Funding: ACH, wire, or in-branch deposit. Compounding: Monthly (vs daily at Marcus/Ally — minor difference at these rates). Partial withdrawals: Not allowed.
A Multi-Year Guaranteed Annuity (MYGA) is the insurance industry's version of a CD: lock a rate for X years, get it back at maturity. Different chassis (insurance contract, not bank deposit), but the experience is nearly identical. Two big differences matter — and they matter a lot at the 5-year horizon where Capital One's curve is weakest:
1. The rate gap. As of June 2026:
| Vehicle | 5-Year Rate | $250K Growth (5yr) |
|---|---|---|
| Capital One 360 5-Year CD | ~3.85% | ~$51,990 |
| Top 5-Year MYGA | ~5.50% | ~$72,910 |
| MYGA advantage | +1.65% | +$20,920 |
2. Tax deferral. CDs throw a 1099-INT every January whether you take the interest or not — you pay tax now on money you haven't touched. MYGAs defer all gains until withdrawal, so the interest compounds on pre-tax dollars. For a buyer in the 32% federal bracket, that tax-deferral effect adds the equivalent of another ~15–20% boost to your real after-tax yield over 5 years.
Trade-offs are real: MYGAs have surrender charges (typically 7–9% in year 1 dropping to 0% at maturity), no FDIC (state-guaranty-association coverage instead — usually $250K–$300K depending on state), and a 10% IRS penalty on gains pre-59½ if non-qualified. For money you genuinely won't touch for 5+ years and are okay holding to maturity, MYGAs win on a risk-adjusted basis — and the gap is largest exactly where Capital One's 360 CD lineup is weakest.
See: 5-Year MYGA — Peace of Mind Review
Capital One 360 CDs are fine for what they are: simple, FDIC-backed, $0 minimum, integrated with the broader Capital One ecosystem and with branch access if you want it. The 1-year at 4.50% is competitive. If you already bank at Capital One, opening a 360 CD for short-term cash is a reasonable click.
But Capital One's curve flattens hard past 18 months — 3- through 5-year all sit at 3.85%, which is a clear "we don't want this money" pricing signal. For any 5-year lock, you should at least compare to a MYGA. A 5-year MYGA from a top A-rated carrier currently pays ~5.50% vs Capital One's 3.85%, and that ~$20,920 difference on $250K compounds further when you factor in CDs being taxed annually while MYGAs defer. And remember: no partial withdrawals on Capital One CDs means if life happens at year 3, you crack the whole CD. CDs and MYGAs aren't competitors — they're complements for different time horizons.
About Hans Goldstein: Independent retirement income specialist. CA Life License #4163961. NPN #20602398. Reviews 30+ carriers + every major online bank. Phone: 213-414-2808. Email: hans@goldsteinco.net.
The more complex a product, the worse it scores. Complexity is where buyers get burned. CDs are about as simple as financial products get — which is why they score so well here.
Capital One 360 CDs are pure-vanilla: one APY, one term, one penalty. The only mild twist worth noting is the no-partial-withdrawal rule — break it and you break the whole CD. Otherwise, audit-able in 30 seconds.
| Dimension | Score (1–10) | What this measures |
|---|---|---|
| Riders | 0/10 | CDs have no riders. Nothing to opt into, nothing to pay extra for. |
| Crediting strategies | 1/10 | One fixed APY for the entire term. No caps, participation rates, spreads, or indices. |
| Surrender complexity | 3/10 | Early withdrawal penalty = 3 months interest (≤12mo) or 6 months interest (longer). No partial withdrawals adds slight complexity — break some, break all. |
| Benefit-base separation | 0/10 | Account value IS the value. No phantom "benefit base" lurking elsewhere. |
| Bonus structure | 0/10 | No bonus. No vesting. No recapture. The rate you see is the rate you get. |
Why this matters: Simplicity is a feature. The Capital One 360 CD is fully audit-able. The trade-off is yield: that simplicity is partly why the bank only pays you ~3.85% on 5-year money — there's no fancy structure squeezing more return out of the spread.
A Certificate of Deposit (CD) is a piggy bank with a contract. You hand the bank money, and they promise to pay you a guaranteed interest rate for a fixed period — say, 1 year at 4.50%. In exchange, you agree not to touch the money until the year is up. If you do, the bank takes back some of the interest as a penalty.
The math:
- Put $10,000 into a Capital One 360 1-year CD at 4.50% APY
- After 1 year, you have $10,450 ($450 interest)
- Withdraw early at month 6: bank keeps 3 months of interest = roughly $112 forfeited, AND you have to crack the whole CD (no partials)
- Hold to maturity: full $10,450 plus a 10-day grace period to decide what's next
The "fees" are non-existent:
- No monthly fee, no funding fee, no maintenance fee, no minimum
- The bank makes money by lending your deposit out at ~6–8% and paying you ~4.50%
- Your only "cost" is the opportunity cost if rates go up and you're stuck
The safety net:
- FDIC insures up to $250,000 per depositor per bank — federally backed, never failed to pay
- If Capital One N.A. failed, you'd get your money back within days
Talk to a licensed independent expert. Hans.
Before you lock a 5-year CD at Capital One's flat 3.85%, see what the top-shelf MYGAs are actually paying right now and whether tax-deferral helps your situation. Independent, no carrier loyalty, no quotas.
Drop your info — within 24 hours, you'll get a side-by-side written comparison of the Capital One 360 CD you're considering vs. the top 3 MYGAs available to you, plus a no-pressure 15-minute call if you want one.
📞 Hans Goldstein · 213-414-2808 · NPN 20602398, independent licensed insurance producer appointed with multiple A-rated carriers
By submitting, you agree to receive calls and texts from Hans Goldstein. Msg/data rates apply. Reply STOP to opt out. Privacy Policy.
This review reflects publicly available Capital One rate sheets and FDIC filings as of the date stated above. CD APYs change frequently — sometimes weekly. Always confirm current rates at capitalone.com before opening an account. This article is general information for educational purposes; it is not a personalized recommendation, solicitation, or offer of any specific bank or insurance product. Hans Goldstein is an independent licensed insurance producer (NPN 20602398) appointed with multiple A-rated annuity carriers; Hans is not a bank employee, not affiliated with Capital One, and receives no compensation from any bank for this review. Comparisons between CDs and MYGAs reflect representative top-of-market rates as of June 2026 and are illustrative — your individual rate, tax situation, and suitability will vary. Always read the actual CD disclosure or annuity contract and consult a licensed advisor before purchasing. FDIC coverage is subject to current FDIC rules and the $250,000 per-depositor, per-bank, per-ownership-category limit. State guaranty association coverage on annuities varies by state. Tax treatment is subject to change.