Is it better to put stocks or CDs inside my Roth IRA?

Depends on time horizon. Under 5 years to spending = CD. Over 15 years = stocks. 5-15 years = blend, weighted toward fixed-income as you approach the spending date. Roth IRAs benefit from the longest time horizon possible because they have no RMD.

Why should the Roth typically have more stocks than my Traditional IRA?

Roth has no RMD during your lifetime, so it usually becomes the longest-held account. Long horizons favor equity. Spend Traditional and taxable first; let Roth compound.

What is sequence-of-returns risk?

The risk that poor investment returns happen in the 5 years before and after retirement — the retirement risk zone. Two portfolios with identical average 30-year returns can produce dramatically different outcomes if the timing of returns differs. Bad early returns cannot be recovered once you are withdrawing.

How much of my Roth IRA should be in CDs?

At ages 25-50: 0-20%. At ages 50-60: 20-40%. At ages 60-75 (retirement risk zone): 30-50%. After age 75: 20-40% (back to a growth tilt for legacy purposes).

Should I use a Roth IRA MYGA instead of a Roth IRA CD?

For the fixed-income portion of your Roth, yes — A-rated Roth IRA MYGAs typically pay 100-150 bps more than equivalent Roth IRA CDs at 5-year terms in the same tax wrapper.

Can I have both a Roth IRA CD and Roth IRA stocks in the same account?

Yes, but usually they live in separate Roth IRAs — one at a brokerage (for the equity sleeve) and one at a bank/credit union (for the CD sleeve). Both count toward the same combined contribution limit.

What is the 5-year Roth rule?

For qualified tax-free distributions of earnings, your Roth IRA must have been open at least 5 tax years AND you must be 59½ or older (both required). The 5-year clock starts January 1 of the year of your first Roth contribution to any Roth IRA.

Should I shift my Roth from stocks to CDs as I get closer to retirement?

Some shift makes sense in the retirement risk zone (ages 60-75) to manage sequence risk. The shift should be partial — typically not more than 50% out of equity — because Roth is your longest-held legacy asset and benefits from continued equity growth.

Roth IRA Allocation GuideLast updated: 2026-06-27Author: Hans Goldstein, NPN 20602398

Roth IRA CD vs Roth IRA Stocks — Which Allocation Wins?

TL;DR: Roth IRA CD: ~4-5% fixed, FDIC-insured, no volatility, no growth above the contracted rate. Roth IRA stocks (broad equity index fund): ~7-9% expected long-term return, but year-to-year returns range from -50% to +50%. Decision framework: time horizon matters most. Under 5 years to spending need = CD. Over 15 years = stocks. 5-15 years = blend, with the CD share rising as you approach the spending horizon. Sequence-of-returns risk — the order in which returns happen — matters far more in the 5 years before and after retirement than at any other time.

The core trade-off

A Roth IRA CD locks in a known nominal rate (typically 4-5% in mid-2026) for a fixed term. There is essentially zero year-to-year volatility — the CD pays the contracted rate, period. Inflation can erode the real value but the nominal return is guaranteed.

A Roth IRA invested in a broad equity index fund (VTI, VOO, SPY, IVV, etc.) has historically produced ~9-10% nominal annual returns over rolling 30-year periods — meaningfully above any CD rate. The catch: that average return is the geometric mean of a sequence that includes years like +37% (1995), -37% (2008), +29% (2024), and -19% (2022). Year-to-year you do not know what you will get.

Why time horizon dominates the decision

Equity volatility shrinks dramatically as the holding period lengthens. Historical data on S&P 500 rolling-period returns:

Holding period	Best annualized return	Worst annualized return	Median annualized
1 year	+54%	-43%	+10%
5 years	+29%	-12%	+10%
10 years	+20%	-3%	+10%
20 years	+18%	+1%	+10%
30 years	+13%	+5%	+10%

Read the 20-year row carefully: the worst rolling 20-year S&P 500 return in modern history was +1% annualized. That includes 2000-2020 (dot-com crash + GFC + COVID). The median 20-year return is +10%. The CD pays 4-5%. Over a 20-year horizon, the equity allocation has essentially never lost to the CD in real terms.

Read the 1-year row: equity can lose 43% in a single year. If you need the money in 12 months, you cannot afford that outcome — even if it is the exception, not the rule.

Sequence-of-returns risk — the retirement-window problem

The most damaging risk to a Roth IRA in retirement is not bad long-run returns; it is bad returns concentrated in the first 5-10 years of withdrawal. Here is why.

Suppose you retire at 65 with $1,000,000 in a Roth IRA and plan to withdraw $40,000 per year (4% rule). Two scenarios with identical 30-year average returns but different sequences:

Good first decade: +10%/year average for years 1-10, then variable for years 11-30. You withdraw $40K/year against a balance that grows to ~$1.5M by year 10. Easily sustainable for 30+ years.
Bad first decade: -3%/year average for years 1-10, then +15%/year for years 11-30 to make the 30-year average identical. You withdraw $40K/year against a balance that shrinks to ~$500K by year 10. The portfolio cannot recover — you run out of money around year 22 despite identical "average" returns.

This is sequence-of-returns risk. It is the reason every retirement-income textbook recommends a higher fixed-income allocation in the 5 years before and after retirement — the retirement risk zone — than at any other point in life.

A practical allocation framework by age

Age	Years to spending need	Roth IRA CD/MYGA	Roth IRA equity
25-35	30-40 years	0-10%	90-100%
35-50	15-30 years	10-20%	80-90%
50-60	5-15 years	20-40%	60-80%
60-65 (retirement risk zone)	0-5 years	30-50%	50-70%
65-75 (retirement risk zone)	spending now	30-50%	50-70%
75+	spending now, legacy	20-40%	60-80%

The fixed-income allocation rises into the retirement risk zone and falls back down once you are 10+ years past retirement (because at that point your sequence risk is behind you and you are back to playing for long-run growth on the legacy portion).

How IRA CD taxation actually works

This is the single most misunderstood point. An IRA CD is taxed like any other IRA asset, not like a taxable bank CD.

Inside a Traditional IRA: Interest credited each year is not reported on your 1040. You do not get a 1099-INT for IRA CD interest. The CD compounds tax-deferred. You only owe tax when you withdraw — and withdrawals are taxed as ordinary income.
Inside a Roth IRA: Interest is never taxed, provided your withdrawal is qualified (you are age 59½ or older and the Roth has been open at least 5 years).
What you owe each year: Nothing. Zero. The annual 1099-INT that taxable CD holders receive does not apply to IRA CDs.
What triggers tax: The withdrawal (Traditional) or a non-qualified Roth distribution. The CD's interest crediting cycle is irrelevant for tax purposes.

If you are under age 59½ and withdraw, two penalties can stack: the bank's early withdrawal penalty (typically 90–365 days of interest) and the IRS 10% additional tax on the withdrawn amount. The bank's penalty is enforced by the bank; the IRS penalty is enforced via Form 5329 on your tax return.

Why Roth specifically benefits from this framework

Roth IRA assets are the most valuable asset class you own in retirement because (a) they have no RMD during your lifetime, and (b) every withdrawal is tax-free. The general retirement-income guidance is to spend Traditional IRA and taxable accounts first, and let the Roth compound the longest. This means the Roth often becomes your legacy account — held to age 85+ before significant withdrawals.

If the Roth is the longest-held account, it should usually have the highest equity allocation, not the lowest. Reserve the CD/MYGA allocation for Traditional IRA and taxable accounts where the spending happens earlier.

When a MYGA beats an IRA CD

An IRA MYGA (multi-year guaranteed annuity) is, in plain English, a CD-equivalent issued by an insurance carrier instead of a bank. Inside an IRA wrapper, both are tax-deferred — the tax wrapper is identical. The difference is the rate, the insurance backing, and the surrender mechanics.

Feature	IRA CD (bank)	IRA MYGA (insurance)
Typical 5 years rate (mid-2026)	~4.20%	~5.60%
Tax treatment inside IRA	Deferred	Deferred (identical)
Insurance / guaranty	FDIC $250K per depositor per bank	State guaranty fund, typically $250K–$300K per owner per carrier; backed by carrier balance sheet
Early access	Pay 90–365 days interest, get principal back	10% free withdrawal annually most carriers; surrender charge on excess
Rate lock-in length	3 months to 5 years typical	3 to 10 years; 5-year is most common

Worked example — $100,000 for 5 years:

IRA CD at 4.20%: $122,840 at maturity
IRA MYGA at 5.60%: $131,317 at maturity
MYGA advantage: ~$8,477 over the 5-year period on the same starting balance

The rate gap exists because MYGA carriers hold longer-duration corporate bonds than banks hold; banks fund CDs primarily with short Treasuries. Inside an IRA — where you cannot use the principal for spending anyway until 59½ without penalty — locking up for the full term costs you nothing extra. The MYGA is structurally a better fit for IRA money the same way it is for taxable money, with one added consideration: the tax-deferred wrapper is "redundant" inside an IRA, but that does not make the MYGA worse — it just means you are paying for an insurance product purely on rate, not on tax shelter. And on rate, it usually wins.

See IRA CD vs MYGA decision guide and current best MYGA rates.

When a Roth IRA CD or MYGA is the right call inside the Roth

You are 5-10 years from retirement and want to lock in some Roth dollars at a known rate to fund the early-retirement spending years.
You have already shifted equity allocation in Traditional and taxable, and want some fixed-income inside Roth specifically to maintain overall asset allocation.
You have a known short-horizon spending need (helping a child with a down payment, paying for a wedding, etc.) coming out of the Roth.
You are uncomfortable with equity volatility regardless of horizon — in which case a CD/MYGA inside Roth is psychologically sustainable while an equity allocation might cause you to panic-sell at the wrong time.

What happens at age 73 with RMDs?

Under SECURE Act 2.0, Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs) begin at age 73 for Traditional IRA holders (and SEP/SIMPLE IRA holders). Roth IRAs have no RMD during the original owner's lifetime. For an IRA CD, the practical issue is liquidity: if your full IRA balance is locked in a single 5-year CD, you may need to break the CD to take your RMD. Two solutions:

Ladder. Hold multiple smaller CDs maturing in different years; pull RMD from the maturing rung. See IRA CD ladder strategy.
RMD-friendly product. Most IRA MYGAs allow penalty-free withdrawal of the RMD amount each year — ask the carrier in writing before signing.

Related guides

Second opinion before you commit IRA money

Independent licensed producer. Hans Goldstein.

IRA money is retirement money — one bad rollover or product pick costs you years. Before you lock a 5-year IRA CD or sign a MYGA application, get a written side-by-side comparison from a licensed independent producer who is not paid by the bank or the carrier you are considering.

Drop your info — within 24 hours you'll get a written rate comparison (IRA CDs vs IRA MYGAs at your term), the IRS rollover rules that apply to your situation, and a no-pressure 15-minute call if you want one.

Hans Goldstein · 213-414-2808 · NPN 20602398, independent licensed insurance producer appointed with multiple A-rated carriers

By submitting, you agree to receive calls and texts from Hans Goldstein. Msg/data rates apply. Reply STOP to opt out. Privacy Policy.

Disclosure

This review reflects publicly available product materials and approximate rates as of the date stated above. CD rates, IRA account fees, MYGA crediting rates, and IRS rules cited (RMD age 73 under SECURE 2.0, 10% early withdrawal penalty before 59½, Roth 5-year qualified distribution rule, post-2019 SECURE Act 10-year rule for non-spouse inherited IRA beneficiaries) are current as of the publication date and subject to change. Always confirm current rates with the issuer and current tax law with a CPA before opening, rolling over, or withdrawing from any IRA. This article is general information for educational purposes; it is not a personalized recommendation, tax opinion, legal opinion, or offer of any specific product. Hans Goldstein is an independent licensed insurance producer (NPN 20602398) appointed with multiple A-rated annuity carriers; he does not sell bank CDs and is not affiliated with any bank, credit union, or brokerage discussed in any review on this site. No compensation has been received from any bank, credit union, or brokerage in connection with this review. MYGAs are insurance products with surrender charges; bank CDs are FDIC-insured deposit products; credit union CDs are NCUA-insured share certificates. These are different product categories with different protections and trade-offs.