Best Annuities for Highest Death Benefit (2026)
TL;DR: If a death benefit is your primary goal, the answer is almost always a hybrid life+LTC policy, not a traditional annuity. The top 3 entries on this list are all hybrids. Pure annuities occupy positions #4-12 with DBQS scores in the 68-82 range. Single Premium Whole Life beats every annuity for pure death benefit. We rank the top 12 anyway because many buyers already own annuity money and want to optimize the death-benefit pathway from within the annuity universe.
How we rank: the Death Benefit Quality Score
The Death Benefit Quality Score (DBQS) is a 1-100 framework we built to compare what a contract actually delivers to heirs across seven dimensions: guaranteed minimum death benefit (GMDB) structure, whether the MVA is waived at death, spousal continuation pricing, ROP (return of premium) guarantee, leverage on premium (face amount / premium ratio), carrier financial strength, and the legal/tax efficiency of the payout. We explain the full rubric in Death Benefit Quality Score (DBQS) — Annuity Rankings.
This page is the 12-product ranking that comes out of running the DBQS across the 2026 universe.
The hero table: top 12 by DBQS
| # | Product | Type | DBQS | One-line why |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | OneAmerica Asset Care | Hybrid Life+LTC | 95 | Joint-life DB + lifetime LTC pool, A+ carrier; the gold standard for combined legacy and care. |
| 2 | Lincoln MoneyGuard III | Hybrid Life+LTC | 92 | 0-day LTC elimination period + 70% return-of-premium guarantee; strongest pure DB hybrid. |
| 3 | Nationwide CareMatters II | Hybrid Life+LTC | 90 | Cash indemnity LTC (no receipts required) + DB; family-flexibility leader. |
| 4 | Securian SecureCare III | Hybrid Life+LTC | 88 | Budget-tier hybrid; strong DB; A+ carrier; smaller face per dollar but accessible underwriting. |
| 5 | Pacific Life PremierCare | Hybrid Life+LTC | 86 | Traditional hybrid; solid DB; strong carrier; classic structure for the conservative buyer. |
| 6 | Brighthouse Shield Annuity VA + GMDB ROP | VA + GMDB | 80 | High-water-mark VA death benefit; locks gains for heirs; best annuity-only DB structure. |
| 7 | Allianz 222 FIA + PIV | FIA + DB rider | 78 | PIV passes to heirs as DB at death; 52% bonus base; the income/legacy hybrid winner. |
| 8 | Nationwide Peak 10 + Bonus Income+ | FIA + DB rider | 76 | Death benefit rider with rollup pass-through; clean structure. |
| 9 | Athene Ascent Pro Bonus FIA | FIA + DB option | 74 | Enhanced DB option doubles the basic GMDB; A+ carrier; bonus product. |
| 10 | Aspida WealthLock MYGA | MYGA (MVA waived at death) | 72 | Clean MYGA for legacy; full account value to heirs; no MVA penalty at death. |
| 11 | Athene MaxRate MYGA | MYGA (MVA waived at death) | 70 | A+ carrier + MVA waiver = clean MYGA legacy; top rating in the MYGA-for-DB class. |
| 12 | Athene SPIA Cash Refund | SPIA Cash Refund | 68 | Guaranteed return of premium minus payments to beneficiary; the rare SPIA with real DB value. |
The top 12, in detail
#1 OneAmerica Asset Care — DBQS 95
Asset Care is the single most-recommended hybrid in our practice for buyers who want both a death benefit and lifetime LTC protection. The product is structured as a whole life policy with an LTC acceleration rider plus a continuation of benefits rider that extends LTC coverage for life after the base policy LTC pool is exhausted. Death benefit is guaranteed regardless of LTC usage — if no LTC claim is made, the full face amount passes to beneficiaries.
Joint-life option (Asset Care II/III) covers two spouses on a single contract. The LTC pool is shared, the DB pays at second death. For couples, this is often the most capital-efficient structure: $300K of premium can produce $600K+ of leveraged DB at second death and $9,000+/month of LTC coverage for life on both spouses.
MVA-at-death: not applicable (whole life chassis). Spousal continuation: built into the joint-life product. Tax: DB is income-tax-free per IRC §101(a); LTC benefits are tax-free per IRC §7702B. The 95 DBQS reflects best-in-class on every dimension.
#2 Lincoln MoneyGuard III — DBQS 92
MoneyGuard III is the strongest pure-DB hybrid in the market. Lincoln's universal life chassis allows for an aggressive face amount per dollar of premium, and the LTC acceleration rider has a 0-day elimination period (LTC benefits start immediately upon qualifying for the trigger). The product also offers a 70% return-of-premium guarantee — if you change your mind or your circumstances change, you can surrender and recover 70% of premiums paid.
Leverage: a 65-year-old female non-smoker paying $100K single premium typically gets ~$215K face amount + ~$8,600/month LTC pool for 6 years. The face amount drops as LTC is consumed; if no LTC is consumed, the full face passes to heirs income-tax-free.
DBQS 92 (vs Asset Care's 95) because the lifetime LTC continuation isn't built in by default; you can buy a rider for it, but at additional cost. For the buyer focused primarily on DB with LTC as a secondary benefit, MoneyGuard III is the cleaner choice.
#3 Nationwide CareMatters II — DBQS 90
CareMatters II offers cash indemnity LTC benefits — meaning once the LTC trigger is met, monthly benefits are paid in cash with no receipts required and no restrictions on use. Families can use the funds for informal home care, pay a relative, or cover non-traditional caregiving expenses. Most hybrid LTC structures use a reimbursement model requiring receipts; cash indemnity is structurally more family-friendly.
Face amount is competitive but typically 10-15% lower than MoneyGuard for the same premium. The trade-off is the cash-indemnity flexibility. For a buyer who values family discretion in how care is delivered (and not just where), CareMatters wins.
DBQS 90 reflects strong DB plus the LTC cash flexibility. Joint-life option available.
#4 Securian SecureCare III — DBQS 88
SecureCare III is the budget-tier hybrid in our top 5. Smaller face amount per dollar than MoneyGuard or Asset Care, but accessible underwriting (some impaired-risk cases approved) and a competitive premium structure for buyers under $100K of single premium. A+ carrier strength.
DBQS 88. The score reflects a clean DB structure and strong carrier, with a slight discount for face-amount leverage.
#5 Pacific Life PremierCare — DBQS 86
PremierCare is the classic traditional hybrid. Solid DB, strong carrier, conservative LTC structure (reimbursement model, 90-day elimination period). For the buyer who wants a brand-name carrier and a textbook structure without optimization, PremierCare is the conservative pick.
DBQS 86. Slightly lower than CareMatters and SecureCare on innovation features; equal on carrier strength.
#6 Brighthouse Shield Annuity VA + GMDB ROP — DBQS 80
The highest-scoring annuity-only product on the list. Brighthouse Shield's GMDB rider with high-water-mark feature locks gains for heirs — meaning if the contract value reaches $300K then drops back to $220K, the death benefit remains $300K (the high-water mark). The ROP feature guarantees beneficiaries receive at least the original premium regardless of market performance.
The catch: VA subaccount fees (M&E typically 1.0-1.3%) plus the GMDB rider charge (0.3-0.5% annually). The fees compound against returns. For the buyer who wants market exposure with a hard floor for heirs, the structure works; for the buyer indifferent to market exposure, an A-rated MYGA with MVA waiver at death (positions #10-11) often delivers a similar net DB more efficiently.
DBQS 80. Best annuity-structure DB on the list; carrier strength holds it back from competing with the hybrids.
#7 Allianz 222 FIA + PIV — DBQS 78
Allianz 222's PIV (Protected Income Value) was designed as an income-base feature but also passes to heirs as an enhanced death benefit. The 52% bonus on the PIV at activation creates a benefit base substantially larger than the cash value; that base can be paid to beneficiaries over 5 years at death (versus cash value as a lump sum). For income-leaning buyers who also want legacy enhancement, this is the best combined-purpose product.
Caveat: the PIV death benefit is paid in installments, not a lump sum. Heirs who want a lump sum receive only the cash value. The DBQS reflects this hybrid nature — 78 instead of 85+ because the lump-sum option isn't there.
See our full Allianz 222 FIA Review for the PIV mechanics and the IQS scoring.
#8 Nationwide Peak 10 + Bonus Income+ — DBQS 76
Nationwide's Bonus Income+ rider grows a benefit base at 8% annually for up to 10 years. At death, that base passes to heirs as the death benefit (paid over 5 years), creating substantial DB enhancement vs the cash value alone. The 10-year rollup window means a $100K premium becomes a $215K+ death benefit at year 10 even with zero index credits.
DBQS 76. Similar structure to Allianz 222 but with a smaller bonus and tighter rollup window.
#9 Athene Ascent Pro Bonus FIA — DBQS 74
Athene Ascent Pro Bonus is a bonus FIA with an Enhanced DB option that approximately doubles the basic GMDB at death. The base product gives the cash value as the DB; the Enhanced DB option pays the greater of cash value or premium-plus-accumulation at a guaranteed rate. A+ carrier and competitive premium bonus make this a strong combined-purpose product.
DBQS 74. The Enhanced DB option adds value but adds rider cost; net DB delivery is competitive but not best-in-class.
#10 Aspida WealthLock MYGA (MVA waived at death) — DBQS 72
For the buyer who wants a clean, low-complexity legacy vehicle within the annuity wrapper, Aspida WealthLock with MVA waived at death is the highest-scoring MYGA on the DB list. The full account value passes to beneficiaries with no MVA adjustment, no surrender penalty, and no income-tax issue until heirs withdraw. Tax-deferred growth during accumulation; tax due on the deferred gain at withdrawal by heirs (no step-up at death for annuity gains).
DBQS 72. Pure MYGA; no DB amplification; the score reflects clean delivery rather than enhancement.
#11 Athene MaxRate MYGA (MVA waived at death) — DBQS 70
Same structural advantages as Aspida WealthLock with the upgrade to A+ carrier strength. Slightly lower current rate (the carrier strength carries a yield premium against). For the conservative DB-focused buyer who wants the strongest available MYGA carrier with a clean DB pathway, Athene MaxRate is the pick.
DBQS 70. The MYGA structure caps the upside; the A+ rating earns the carrier-strength points.
#12 Athene SPIA Cash Refund — DBQS 68
The only SPIA on the DB top 12. Life-Only SPIAs score in the 10-20 range on DBQS because if the annuitant dies early, payments stop and nothing goes to heirs. The Cash Refund variant of a SPIA guarantees that beneficiaries receive the remaining unpaid premium as a lump sum at death. If the contract is $200K and total payments before death total $80K, beneficiaries receive $120K. Once total payments equal premium, no further DB applies.
The Cash Refund SPIA pays slightly less per month than a Life-Only SPIA (typically 3-5% lower payout factor), in exchange for the refund guarantee. For the income-needing buyer who wants insurance against an early death, this is the structure to consider.
DBQS 68. The refund stops once payments equal premium, so the DB declines over time and reaches zero around the breakeven point.
When a traditional annuity beats a hybrid for death benefit
The honest answer is: rarely. The hybrid life+LTC structures at positions #1-5 deliver more death benefit per dollar than any annuity structure can, because they're built on a life insurance chassis that's purpose-engineered for leveraged death benefit. The annuity universe is built on a different chassis.
Three scenarios where the annuity wins anyway:
- You already have lifetime LTC coverage from another source — A standalone LTC policy from a previous purchase, or a traditional LTC policy with strong lifetime benefits, makes the LTC component of a hybrid redundant. In that case, an annuity-only DB structure (positions #6-12) may deliver better dollar-for-dollar DB without the redundant LTC pricing.
- You can't medically qualify for life insurance underwriting — Hybrid life+LTC requires medical underwriting (some products allow simplified-issue at smaller face amounts). An MYGA with MVA waived at death has effectively no underwriting. For impaired-risk buyers, the annuity may be the only available DB pathway.
- The money is already inside an annuity — If you have an existing annuity with a low cost basis and a substantial deferred gain, a §1035 exchange into a better annuity (preserving deferral) is often better than cashing out and buying a hybrid (triggering ordinary income tax on the full gain). The DB optimization happens within the annuity universe by necessity.
Single Premium Whole Life (SPWL): the unfair winner
If you're optimizing purely for death benefit with no LTC component, no income need, and no liquidity need — and you can medically underwrite — Single Premium Whole Life from a top mutual (Northwestern Mutual, MassMutual, Guardian, NY Life) beats every annuity on this list. The math is simple. A 65-year-old female non-smoker paying $100K single premium typically gets $250K-$300K of guaranteed death benefit, plus participating dividends that grow both the cash value and the death benefit over time. The DB is income-tax-free per IRC §101(a). The cash value grows tax-deferred.
SPWL doesn't make the annuity list because it's not an annuity. We mention it here because the honest analysis for a death-benefit-only buyer should at least include the option. We have a separate review of SPWL vs Annuity for Death Benefit walking through the math at four issue ages and three premium tiers.
If you can't medically underwrite SPWL, or you need income or LTC alongside the DB, the hybrids and the annuity-DB structures on this list become the right path.
Worst death benefit annuities to AVOID
- Life-Only SPIAs — DBQS 5-15. Payments stop at death of annuitant. Nothing to heirs. Catastrophic mis-fit for any buyer with DB intent.
- MYGAs where MVA is applied at death — DBQS 25-45. The Market Value Adjustment, designed to penalize early surrenders in a rising-rate environment, gets applied to the death benefit on some carriers. Heirs receive a haircut to the account value. Read the contract; most A-rated carriers waive the MVA at death, but some do not.
- FIAs with no DB rider and low cash value early — DBQS 30-50. Many FIAs have a low cash value in years 1-5 due to bonus recapture and rate-lock effects; if death occurs early, heirs receive the cash value (not premium-plus-interest). Add a DB rider or buy a different product.
- VAs without GMDB rider — DBQS 30-45. Without a GMDB rider, the DB is just the current contract value — which can be below premium in a market downturn. Pay for the GMDB rider if DB matters.
- Period-Certain-Only SPIAs — DBQS 40-55. If annuitant dies during the certain period, payments continue to beneficiary for the remainder of the period. After the certain period, no further payments. The DB is real but bounded.
Related reading
- Death Benefit Quality Score (DBQS) — Full Framework
- Income Quality Score (IQS) — Ranking Annuities for Income
- Growth Potential Score (GPS) — Ranking Annuities for Accumulation
- Best Annuities for Lifetime Income (2026)
- Best Annuities for Growth Potential (2026)
- OneAmerica Asset Care Review
- Lincoln MoneyGuard III Review
- Nationwide CareMatters II Review
- 5-Year Rule for Inherited Annuities
- Allianz 222 FIA Review (PIV death benefit explained)
Frequently Asked Questions
Why do hybrid life+LTC products dominate the top of the death benefit list?
Because they're built on a life insurance chassis, which is purpose-engineered to deliver leveraged death benefit per dollar of premium. Annuities are built on a different chassis (income or accumulation). The DBQS doesn't punish annuities for what they're not built to do; it just measures what they deliver, which is structurally less.
Does the death benefit from an annuity pass to heirs income-tax-free?
No. The deferred gain inside an annuity is taxable as ordinary income to the beneficiary when withdrawn. Life insurance death benefit, by contrast, passes income-tax-free per IRC §101(a). This is a major structural reason hybrid life+LTC and SPWL outperform annuities on net legacy delivered.
What does "MVA waived at death" mean?
A Market Value Adjustment is a clause that adjusts the surrender value of a MYGA or FIA up or down based on prevailing interest rates relative to the contract rate. Most A-rated carriers waive the MVA at the annuitant's death so beneficiaries receive the full account value. Some carriers do not waive it — read the contract before assuming. The DBQS scores this directly; "MVA waived at death" is a precondition for any meaningful DBQS score on a MYGA.
Can heirs roll over an inherited annuity?
Spousal beneficiaries can elect to continue the annuity as their own (preserving deferral). Non-spousal beneficiaries cannot roll into their own IRA; they must take distributions under the 5-year rule, the stretch rule (if they were eligible designated beneficiaries under SECURE Act 2.0), or via annuitization. See 5-Year Rule for Inherited Annuities for the full mechanics.
How much DB can I get from a $200K hybrid premium?
Roughly $400-$550K of guaranteed face amount for a 60-year-old non-smoker on a top hybrid (Asset Care or MoneyGuard), with $14,000-$18,000/month of LTC benefit for 6 years. Exact figures depend on age, gender, health, and product. A $200K SPWL premium delivers approximately $500-$650K of guaranteed DB plus dividend growth.
Does the death benefit reduce if I take LTC withdrawals from a hybrid?
Yes. The hybrid is one pool of money serving two purposes. LTC dollars used reduce the remaining death benefit dollar-for-dollar. If you use the entire LTC pool, the remaining DB may be reduced to a small "residual" (typically 10% of original face). The mechanics are why Asset Care's lifetime LTC continuation rider matters — it extends LTC coverage beyond the original pool without affecting the residual DB further.
Are these scores updated when carriers change products?
Yes. We refresh the DBQS quarterly and re-rank when a major product feature changes (new rider, repriced premium, structural change). Last update reflected in the meta-strip date above.
Can I combine an annuity for income and a hybrid for death benefit in one plan?
Yes, and many of our highest-conviction plans do exactly this. A SPIA on $200K covers lifetime income; a hybrid on $150K covers DB and LTC; a MYGA on $100K stays liquid. Three products doing three jobs. The combined plan usually outperforms any single-product solution on net household outcomes.
Want the DBQS run on the annuity you've been quoted — vs hybrid alternatives?
Talk to a licensed independent expert. Hans.
If a broker has put an annuity in front of you and pitched the death benefit, get the DBQS computed on that specific product before you sign — and get the comparison vs a hybrid life+LTC alternative for the same premium. Most buyers find that 30-50% more DB is achievable from a different structure they weren't shown.
Drop your info — within 24 hours you'll get a written DBQS analysis of your quote, side-by-side against the top-3 alternatives (including hybrid options), and a 15-minute call if you want one.
Hans Goldstein · 213-414-2808 · NPN 20602398, independent licensed insurance producer appointed with multiple A-rated carriers
By submitting, you agree to receive calls and texts from Hans Goldstein. Msg/data rates apply. Reply STOP to opt out. Privacy Policy.
Disclosure
This article reflects publicly available product materials and approximate features, face amounts, and rider terms as of the date stated above. Annuity and hybrid life+LTC product features, premium structures, and underwriting criteria change frequently. Always confirm current values against the most recent carrier disclosure document and the actual contract before purchasing. The Death Benefit Quality Score (DBQS) is a proprietary scoring framework developed by Hans Goldstein for informational and comparative purposes; it is not endorsed by, affiliated with, or licensed from any carrier or rating agency. This article is general information for educational purposes; it is not a personalized recommendation, solicitation, or offer of any specific product. Hans Goldstein is an independent licensed insurance producer (NPN 20602398) appointed with multiple A-rated carriers across the annuity and long-term care insurance market; specific appointment status with any carrier discussed may vary, and discussion of a carrier is not an endorsement or representation of carrier appointment. No compensation has been received from any carrier in connection with the publication of this article. Always read the actual contract and consult a licensed advisor before purchasing any annuity, life insurance, or long-term care insurance product. Annuities and hybrid life+LTC policies are long-term contracts with surrender charges; they are not suitable for funds you may need before the end of the surrender period. AM Best ratings and tax treatment are subject to change. Tax discussion of IRC §72, §101(a), and §7702B reflects law as of 2026 and is subject to change.